Reel’n Tails Charters Customer Reviews

Name: Reeln Tails Charters
Brand: Reeln Tails Charters
Rating: 5 (44 reviews)

100% would recommend

5/5

From 44
verified reviews

Jack AI Customer Experience Snapshot

Captain Anthony consistently delivers exceptional fishing results, putting guests on tarpon, red grouper, yellowtail snapper, mangrove snapper, jack crevalle, and mahi-mahi across multiple productive spots. His expertise shines through strategic location changes when one area slows down, ensuring continuous action throughout trips. Customers regularly report catching 12-15 fish in short windows, with many landing their first-ever tarpon or personal bests under his guidance. Anthony's personal touch begins before you even hit the water - he calls after booking to discuss targets and share helpful advice. His patience with kids creates magical experiences, like the 12-year-old who caught exactly 12 fish and thanked her dad repeatedly. Guests appreciate his accommodating nature, from adjusting meeting points to working around weather and schedules. Many visitors book return trips specifically with Anthony.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews

Tarpon

Personal_Touch

Accommodating

Multiple_Spots

Patient_Teaching

Family_Friendly

Knowledgeable

Return_Trips

Photos from Real Customers

See all images

Mutton Snapper fish caught while fishing

A blacktip shark being fished in an unknown location

Two people fishing in an unknown location

Successful fishing trip at unknown location

Two people fishing at an unknown location

Perfect day for deep sea jigging and trolling with multiple techniques ready to go!

A lone fisherman enjoys a peaceful day of fishing

A lone angler fishing at an unknown location

Snook, a 24-inch fish, caught while fishing

Angler with a fishing rod in an unknown location

Fishing for a white catfish, 22 inches long

Great fishing adventure at unknown location

A person fishing with a rod in an unknown location

A lone fisherman reeling in a catch at an unknown location.

Two anglers fishing in an unknown location

Eight Mahi Mahi or Common Dolphinfish, 17 inches, fishing

8 mahi mahi or common dolphinfish caught during fishing trip

8 mahi mahi fish caught during fishing trip

Fishing adventure at an unknown location

8 mahi mahi fish caught by 4 people fishing

Photograph of a white catfish, 22 inches long, caught while fishing

8 mahi mahi or common dolphinfish, fishing

Photo of a sandbar shark, a fishing scene at an unknown location.

8 mahi mahi fish caught in an unknown location during a fishing trip

8 mahi mahi or common dolphinfish caught while fishing

2 fishing enthusiasts caught 19-inch fish on an unknown fishing trip

Fisherman catching a white catfish in an unknown location

Eight mahi mahi or common dolphinfish caught while fishing

Sandbar shark caught while fishing at unknown location

A large white catfish caught on a fishing trip

8 mahi mahi or common dolphinfish caught while fishing at an undisclosed location

Photograph of a white catfish measuring 22 inches

8 Mahi Mahi or Common Dolphinfish, 17-inch catch

Mahi Mahi fish caught during fishing trip with 4 people

Catching a big white catfish while fishing

Most Reviewed Trip

Book Your Next Trip With Us

All Reviews

Mike Wolde

December 8, 2025

Trip - Quick Guided Fishing Trip In Key Biscayne - Jack, Tarpon, and More on December 6, 2025

5:00 PM - 7:00 PM

Max 1 guest

Captain Anthony was amazing. We went fishing with him for two hours and it truly felt like the time of our lives. He was incredibly patient with my young daughter, made her feel comfortable, and went out of his way to make the experience special for her. You can tell he loves what he does and takes real pride in giving people a great day on the water. We will be booking him every time we are in Miami.

Guide responseWas this helpful ?

Captain AnthonyReplied on December 8, 2025

Mike Wolde, Thank you! You both were awesome your daughter did an amazinf job and can tell she loves to fish. Looking forward to our next trip.

Mike Wolde

December 8, 2025

Trip - Quick Guided Fishing Trip In Key Biscayne - Jack, Tarpon, and More on December 6, 2025

5:00 PM - 7:00 PM

Max 1 guest

Was this helpful ?

Catherine C

November 30, 2025

Trip - on November 30, 2025

This was an incredible experience! Anthony is an outstanding host—knowledgeable, patient, and great to be around. As a first-time angler, I appreciated how he set everything up and walked me through each step. He even went the extra mile to help my partner go after the fish he was hoping for and spent additional time to make sure the trip was worthwhile. Well worth the booking, and the price is very reasonable. I’ll be booking with him every time I’m in the Miami area!

Was this helpful ?

Devon H

November 25, 2025

Trip - on November 25, 2025

We booked the 2-hour sunset cruise and had an amazing time. Anthony was incredibly flexible and made sure we didn’t miss the sunset, even though it happened earlier than expected. He had everything ready—bait, reels, and a great atmosphere—so all we had to do was show up. On the way out, he even stepped in as our photographer and DJ. With limited time, he made sure we made the most of every minute on the water. His knowledge of the area and the best spots was impressive, and we were hooked up on fish nearly every cast, all with the Miami skyline glowing behind us. We weren’t planning on targeting sharks, but after catching perfect “shark bait,” Anthony suggested giving it a try—and we landed two! They put up a serious fight, and he coached us through the entire process. He handled each shark with respect and made sure the release was quick and safe. Five stars isn’t enough. We couldn’t recommend Anthony more. If you want a genuine, memorable fishing trip, this is the one.

Was this helpful ?

Karla W

November 20, 2025

Trip - on November 20, 2025

A must-do experience! Captain Anthony was fantastic—friendly, knowledgeable, and full of positive energy. Even if you have no idea what to expect at the start, he’ll guide you with patience and make everything feel easy. He focuses on giving guests a great time and put us right on the fish we asked for. When you’re on his boat, he treats you like his top priority. I highly recommend this fishing charter. He truly delivers. Thank you, Anthony—can’t wait to come back!

Was this helpful ?

Zach S

November 17, 2025

Trip - on November 17, 2025

I wanted to take a couple of buddies out to hook into some tarpon, and the captain did an excellent job. We had a great time and got exactly the experience we were hoping for!

Was this helpful ?

Shaun W

November 14, 2025

Trip - on November 14, 2025

We asked Captain Anthony to help us catch a mix of different species, and he did a great job. His knowledge of the local spots had us hooking fish right away, and the bite stayed steady the whole time.

Was this helpful ?

Hoyt G

November 7, 2025

Trip - on November 7, 2025

We asked Captain Anthony to put us on a variety of species, and he absolutely delivered. His knowledge of the local waters had us on fish fast, and the action barely slowed down. Great trip all around!

Was this helpful ?

Paul C

November 1, 2025

Trip - on November 1, 2025

Even on a slower night, we still landed a 50 lb tarpon along with several smaller species. Anthony kept us motivated and made the entire experience worthwhile. Great trip overall!

Was this helpful ?

Mark W

October 11, 2025

Trip - on October 11, 2025

Captain Anthony was excellent—friendly, enthusiastic, and quick to get us on the fish. He was just as excited as we were when we landed each catch. Highly recommend, and if I’m back in Miami, I will definitely be rebooking with Anthony.

Was this helpful ?

William Y

September 19, 2025

Trip - Half Day Night Time Fishing Trip In Miami - Snook, Tarpon, and More on September 19, 2025

7:00 PM - 12:00 AM

We had an unforgettable trip with Captain Anthony. Right after I booked the trip, Anthony called me personally to go over the details and share some helpful advice, which already made me feel confident and excited. On the water, I caught the very first tarpon of my life—it truly felt like a dream come true. We even saw schools of baitfish exploding out of the water, with some jumping right onto the boat! It was an incredible experience from start to finish, and I know this won’t be my last trip. I’ll definitely be back!

Was this helpful ?

Andrew McNamara

September 1, 2025

Trip - Half Day Morning Guided Fishing Trip In Miami - Grouper, Mackerel, and More on August 30, 2025

7:00 AM - 11:00 AM

Max 1 guest

Anthony is fantastic and made it a great experience from the start. Right after booking he called to ask what we were looking to target, talk about options and ideas - excellent hospitality. His communication in the days leading up to our trip was phenomenal as well. I’ve never seen a captain work so hard to put us in fish!!! Would use him again in 2 seconds!

Was this helpful ?

Explore The Hidden Gems Of Key Biscayne Fishing Charters

About Reeln Tails Charters Business Reviews

The Reel’n Tails Charters Review Page is where our customers can share their unforgettable fishing experiences with us and future anglers. After each Key Biscayne fishing trip, we encourage guests to leave their feedback, offering insights into their adventures, from deep sea fishing to inshore fishing Key Biscayne. This page serves as a valuable resource for those looking to book with us, showcasing real reviews from guests who have enjoyed private fishing charters Key Biscayne, family-friendly fishing trips Key Biscayne, and sportfishing excursions. Customers can share their thoughts on the expertise of our Key Biscayne fishing guides, the quality of our equipment, and the excitement of their catches. We pride ourselves on providing the best fishing charters in Key Biscayne, and the reviews reflect our commitment to delivering exceptional service. By reading these firsthand experiences, potential clients can gain confidence in choosing Reel’n Tails Charters for their next fishing adventure. We value every review and continuously strive to improve based on our guests’ feedback, ensuring every trip is memorable.

Reeln Tails Charters Customer Reviews are provided by our guests. We focus on providing our Key Biscayne Fishing Charter guests the very best experience. Our Fishing reviews are from trips in Atlantic Ocean, Biscayne Bay.